State Senator J. D. Mesnard speaking with attendees at the 2022 Annual Awards Luncheon at Republic National Distributing Company of Arizona in Phoenix, June 9, 2022. (Photo: Gage Skidmore)
Exclusive: Mesnard Warns About Democrats’ School Choice Crackdown
It’s the “most damaging” step Dems could take, he says
By RC Maxwell, November 18, 2026 8:06 am
In an exclusive interview with the Arizona Globe, outgoing State Senator JD Mesnard said school choice is the top issue under the new Democratic trifecta, warning it is “the most damaging” step Democrats could take for Arizona families and kids.
Mesnard, a longtime Republican who served as House Speaker and helped expand the state’s Empowerment Scholarship Account program, said that while he has concerns about other parts of the Democratic agenda, school choice stands out as the most troubling. “When I think of all of the things they can do that will be the most damaging to Arizona families and kids, that’s at the top of the list,” he said.
Mesnard said it comes down to the question of “why do they believe they won?” He pointed out that policy issues on Arizona’s ballot largely went the direction of Republicans, and noted that Proposition 212, which would have imposed a $150,000 household income cap, failed to qualify for the ballot after falling short of the required number of valid signatures. “That is middle class for a family of four or five. That’s not rich,” he said. “Measures deliberately designed to kick people off the program.” Mesnard called on Republicans to bring affected parents to the Capitol to tell their stories directly.
For Arizona Republicans, minority status is unfamiliar territory. The party has controlled the House for 60 years and last faced a Democratic trifecta in 1966. The “blue tsunami” that swept through the state even knocked off popular figures like Mesnard, who lost a justice of the peace race in Chandler that many had viewed as a near-certain win for the longtime legislator.
To protect core legislation passed over the past two decades, Mesnard urged Republicans to be strategic with their resistance. “Pick your battles, school choice is absolutely one of them,” he said. Mesnard also stressed the need for party unity. Despite political and personality differences among members, he said, the caucus must focus on holding together. “There’s less flexibility to be rogue, maverick or loner or you’re forming smaller minorities.”
Mesnard’s warning came on the heels of Arizona House Majority Leader-elect Rep. Nancy Gutierrez pledging that the Democrat majority means things will be “different” in Arizona. Their stated priorities include increasing public school funding, labor law revisions, rollbacks of earlier immigration measures, election reforms and previously stated restrictions on the state’s ESA policy.
House Speaker-elect Oscar De Los Santos and Senate President-elect Priya Sundareshan will control the gavels when the Legislature convenes, and both have identified the ESA program as a top target. Mesnard said the new majority’s direction is hard to predict because some new members are complete unknowns. “Are they going to run really crazy stuff that will run them out of office or are they going to temper” it, he asked. The legislature, he says, will be full of people who “didn’t expect to be down there.”
- Exclusive: Mesnard Warns About Democrats’ School Choice Crackdown - November 18, 2026
- New Democratic Majorities Positioned to Rewrite School Choice, Election, and Immigration Laws - November 5, 2026
- Arizona’s Family Revises Facebook Post That Confused Tennessee and Arizona Governor’s Races - August 3, 2026



