Michelle Ugenti-Rita won a Scottsdale City Council seat after a bitter campaign of attack ads, outside spending and accusations of corporate meddling. Now she’s promising a rough term for one of her colleagues.
“It’s going to be very bumpy for her,” Ugenti-Rita told the Arizona Globe, referring to Councilwoman Solange Whitehead, whom she called “a flat out unabashed liar.”
Whitehead, a two-term incumbent who won reelection outright in July, isn’t eager to openly return fire. She dismissed attempts by Ugenti-Rita and incumbent Barry Graham to draw her into a personal feud as middle-school politics.
“I’m elected to get a job done,” Whitehead told the Globe.
The conflict is coming to a council that just survived an unusually rancorous election—and a city that voted differently from much of Arizona and the nation. While Democrats captured the Legislature, Scottsdale elected the conservative pair of Ugenti-Rita and Graham to its two remaining council seats. Whitehead, a registered Democrat, had already secured the third seat.
A campaign with few gloves on
A campaign video featuring Ugenti-Rita and comedian Rob Schneider mocked Whitehead as “Sewage Solange” over her support for expanding purified wastewater use. Better Together, a political action committee, received $335,000 from a Virginia-based PAC and funded advertising against Ugenti-Rita, Graham and former Councilman Bob Littlefield. The conservative slate accused people connected to Axon, the Scottsdale-based Taser and body-camera company, of trying to influence the election; a direct Axon funding link to that PAC has not been established.
Ugenti-Rita called rival Raoul Zubia a “DSA-endorsed socialist.” Zubia, a self-described moderate, publicly rejected the Democratic Socialists of America chapter’s endorsement, saying it came without his knowledge or consent, though he gladly accepted the support of Whitehead.
The final unofficial results gave Ugenti-Rita 53,863 votes, Graham 53,570 and Zubia 51,136—a 2,434-vote margin for the last seat.
Whitehead argues that Littlefield’s August withdrawal gave the two better-known conservatives an advantage, leaving three candidates for two seats instead of four.
Ugenti-Rita has a different explanation: Scottsdale is conservative, and voters appreciated that she never tried to disguise it.
“I literally ran in a nonpartisan race, my first sentence was ‘I’m a lifelong Republican,’” she said.
She believes Republicans elsewhere paid for trying to soften their image during a Democratic wave.
“They ran to the middle and became non-identifiable,” she said. “That’s a recipe for losing because the voters can’t distinguish between who’s who.”
Ugenti-Rita, who described the contest as her ninth race and seventh win, credited consistency, name recognition and a city of business-minded, fiscally conservative voters.
“I literally just stayed the course for 15 years,” she said.
Whitehead rejects the idea that this is simply a partisan story. She points to her own reelection and her work on the McDowell Sonoran Preserve, the general plan and the 2019 bond measures.
“I don’t believe we had a blue or red wave,” she said. “I’m not elected to win, I’m elected to get things done.”
But on one subject, their versions of Scottsdale overlap: apartments.
“Our community loves the preserve and hates apartments,” Whitehead said. “I can knock on a door with a Bernie sign and they’ll yell about apartments,” she added, saying she hears the same complaint at homes with Trump signs.
Axon: same fight, opposite conclusions
The campaign’s biggest development battle centered on Axon’s headquarters campus. The company initially sought 2,552 residential units; a roughly 1,900-unit version won council approval in 2024. Opponents qualified a referendum, but a 2025 state law created a route around the local vote. The city later struck a compromise allowing 600 apartments and 600 condominiums. A legal fight over the state intervention continued into 2026.
“Axon is a company, but the issue is really overdevelopment,” Ugenti-Rita said. She sees an employer using its clout—and the Legislature—to override residents.
“Axon threw a temper tantrum,” she said.
Whitehead said Axon’s first proposal was “outrageous,” but she considers the smaller project a defensible deal that keeps a major employer in Scottsdale.
“In five years it’ll be hard to believe that some local politicians tried to push it out,” she said.
Each accuses the other side of ignoring voters. Ugenti-Rita sees the lost referendum as the point. Whitehead sees a negotiated reduction in density—and argues that political money whose ultimate backers deserve scrutiny artificially amplified the fight.
The battle continues
Ugenti-Rita accused Whitehead of masquerading as a fiscal conservative while supporting higher taxes, bigger budgets and development.
“She’ll sound like a Republican all the while there’s not a tax increase she won’t support, a bloated budget she won’t advocate and champion,” Ugenti-Rita said.
Whitehead doesn’t conceal her party registration.
“I’m a registered Democrat, but I’m American,” she said. “I don’t identify as partisan. When you run a city, it doesn’t have anything to do with a party.”
Whitehead promises to debate proposals, not personalities. After Ugenti-Rita and Graham won earlier this month, she immediately took to Facebook to graciously offer her sincere congratulations. They’re colleagues with political differences, not personal enemies.
“I have criticized Barry’s votes. I have never criticized anyone personally,” she said. “At the end of the day once the vote happens, I’ll move on.”
Ugenti-Rita, meanwhile, plans to scrutinize her colleague’s statements and votes. But she also insists the inevitable coming confrontations aren’t personal.
“I’m happy to have her over for Thanksgiving,” she said. “This is business.”
- Jacob Weinberg Finds His People in Chandler - November 20, 2026
- EXCLUSIVE: Scottsdale Stayed Red. Its City Hall Fight Is Just Beginning - November 19, 2026
- Dems Didn’t Think Elaine Aldrete Could Win. Then She Beat T.J. Shope. - November 16, 2026